Last winter I began volunteering at a horse farm that offers equine therapy (also known as hippotherapy) to children with a wide range of disabilities. My role, as a “sidewalker”, is to walk next to the horse and rider to ensure safety and compliance for the child as they engage in various therapeutic modalities atop a horse. Most of the horses at this facility are elderly, and exceptionally well trained. After many years spent schlepping children around on their backs, they know what is expected of them and are unlikely to deviate from their norm, even if a child decides to go rogue and attempt a riding feat he or she is not equipped to handle. One afternoon last February, however, a new horse entered the ring. She was tall, and proud – standing with her head high – and very alert with eyes intent on surveying her surroundings in a way that the older horses no longer bothered to. I was told she was young – only 6 – her name was Fire and that my rider would be paired with her that day.
At various times throughout the session, like during mounting and dismounting, the horses are required to stand still. I quickly learned, however, that Fire did not like to stand still. Intent on quad-pedal movement, Fire made mounting challenging, though we persisted, and were eventually successful. We were, however, unable to alter the rider’s stirrups as a requirement for that basic task is a horse not in motion! Dogs and people pace when they are anxious. I know little about horses, vastly less than I know about my own species or the species for which I’m responsible at my dog daycare, but I would surmise that this compulsion to walk indicated a general sense of unease for Fire. Given her age, and relative inexperience in the ring, some of this was to be expected.
As the session continued, Fire began appearing more agitated, flailing her head back and forth, attempting a hurried gait for which we were not prepared, and ignoring the handler’s attempts to mollify her. The handler, a seasoned rider and horse owner herself, remarked aloud to anyone within earshot that “this horse is not ready for this.” Having very limited knowledge of horses, and only a scant amount of experience as a “side walker”, I said nothing, refusing to confirm or deny this claim. I did, however, note that this horse was acting very, very differently than all the other horses I’d seen come through this place.
As Fire’s pace increased along with her resolve to move, the handler was forced to walk her in circles with me jogging alongside. As fatigue began setting in for us both, the handler called out to the instructor in charge that “This horse is not ready for this”! “I disagree,” the instructor said, “and if you can’t handle her, I will.”
I’ve noted in my profession that people who do not work with animals don’t understand how subjective the work can be. Mammals, like dogs and horses, while less complex than humans, are capable of a complicated spectrum of emotions and breadth of behaviors that can be interpreted in vastly different ways depending on the handler or trainer. Because of the work that I do, I had a suspicion that both women that day were at least partially correct. Fire was inexperienced, at least relatively speaking, and somewhat uncompliant, but she was not wild nor without training. Fire could make it through the session, with the understanding that our expectations of her that day would have to change. With the instructor’s challenge, the handler acquiesced, and we spent the next forty-five minutes briskly walking around the arena, which proved enjoyable enough for the rider, who enjoyed the faster than usual pace of this horse but was unconventional in that we did not participate in the group activities or attempt any additional therapeutic modalities that are typical of classes at this facility. After the class the instructor and the handler thanked me for remaining calm. And I did not see Fire again in any of my classes for seven months.
The next time I saw Fire, her demeanor appeared much more relaxed. Her head was held lower, her eyes looked softer, and she stood – in place! – calmly. Mounting and adjusting the stirrups of the rider was executed without incident. Indeed, it was clear that this horse had undergone additional training, and – naturally – had matured into a calmer and more confident therapeutic riding horse. While she still had some quirks, like a disdain for tight reins, she was, overall, a much more adjusted horse in the ring.
As anyone living in Massachusetts knows, we have been experiencing drought conditions so extreme that wildfires have been breaking out throughout the state, some not far from the horse farm at which I volunteer. Locals, including myself, have been praying to the rain gods for relief. A few weeks ago, our prayers were answered mid-class. The rain falling on the tin roof of the large horse arena was like music to the ears of many (if not all) of the adults that day. That same rain, however, was akin to a gunshot for young Fire. As the sky opened, Fire became spooked, increasing her consistent pace, trotting in circles and bucking in a way that was unsafe for the rider. Fire’s very young horse handler that day did an expert job at holding on to her throughout this. The fast-acting, veteran instructor arrived quickly to assist, and we executed an emergency dismount of the rider. Due to the skilled and experienced staff and volunteers at this facility, no animals or humans were hurt, and the child was mostly unfazed.
From my work with dogs, I know that training is contextual, granular, and dependent on myriad variables, many of which will change, naturally. If you do A and B, the animal does C. But what if “Big B” is changed to “little b”, what does the animal do then? This is another reason that exposing animals to a wide range of people, places and things whilst maintaining boundaries for them in each situation is critical. We can’t predict the future, but we can prepare for it.
Fire is not a failure, she simply needs some additional arena training in the rain. What some may see as regression, I see as reframing. Progress over perfection. Because, in life as well as with animals, the only constant is change.


